Maybe we should talk about what went down in the sheets of summer
Maybe all that water wilted was real and not a mirage
I found your earring the other day in the glove compartment of the car
We used to drive into the sunset
Into the stars
I wonder if I should have stayed when I left you crying on the bench way back in Evanston
When I up and walked away
To love and not love you
Feet from where we laughed about the job you had last summer
Just beyond the willow tree above the pond
Whose wilting branches gently weep for the promises
I would have failed to keep if we ever talked about the 'why' at all
To love and not love you
Tell me, Grace, did you recover from then?
Tell me, Grace, is your heart fully on the mend?
Tell me where, tell me how, we could be together here and now
Tell me Grace, did I make the right call when I loved and didn't love you
So here's to you and all that went down in the sheets of summer
Here's to almond wine and chilling on the lawn
To swim from sea to shining sea
Up top, Hands Down
Above the sheets of cookies, beyond the sheets of stars
Oh, Grace, tell me did you recover from then?
Tell me, Grace, is your heart fully on the mend?
Tell me where, tell me how, we could be together here and now
Tell me Grace, did I make the right call when
I loved and didn't love you
To love and not love you
I loved and didn't love, to love and not love
I love and don't love you
Share it softly, shout it loud
If you mean it, say it proud
Oh Grace, we are just a little bit older now
Tell me where, tell me how, we could be together here and now
Tell me, Grace, did you recover from then?
Tell me, Grace, is your heart fully on the mend?
Tell me where, tell me how, we could be together here and now
Oh Grace, tell me please; did you love or not love me?