There's a number on a napkin
Written in red ink
Waiting by the phone collecting dust
I probably ought to call her
I ain't doing anything
But darling, I just can't get over us
Because you make it look easy
Living life like nothing's wrong
You wanted to leave me
But you won't leave me alone
Cuz I'm brokenhearted, lonely, in a messed up state of mind
Baby, you moved on
Why Can't I
There's a girl at church on Sunday
I've been talking to
I've got half a mind to ask her out
I'd like to get to know her
I know she likes me too
But I'm not in a good place right now
Because you make it look easy
Living life like nothing's wrong
You wanted to leave me
But you won't leave me alone
Cuz I'm brokenhearted, lonely, in a messed up state of mind
Baby, you moved on
Why Can't
I find the strength to hate you
For everything you put me through
I'm still holding on to wasted time
You make it look easy
Living life like nothing's wrong
You wanted to leave me
But you won't leave me alone
Cuz I'm brokenhearted, lonely, in a messed up state of mind
Baby, you moved on
Why Can't I
Why Can't I